The government has given the strongest indication yet that it will be seeking to regulate the Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) market soon, with the release of a consultation paper on the appropriate regulatory approach for emerging financial products to ensure access to credit while protecting consumers.
How Big Is the BNPL Market in Australia?
The Reserve Bank of Australia has estimated that there were approximately 7m active BNPL accounts, making $16bn in transactions in the 2021-22 financial year. This represents an increase of around 37% on the previous year.
Low-value BNPL products that typically provide a spending limit of $2,000 are the most popular in Australia, although spending limits of up to $30,000 are available with some providers for large-ticket items such as home upgrades.
Why BNPL Is Currently Unregulated
Currently, the BNPL space is unregulated in Australia because it falls under the exemptions available to certain types of credit under the Credit Act.
Due to this exemption, BNPL products are not subject to responsible lending standards or other requirements of the Credit Act. In addition, providers do not need to hold an Australian Credit Licence (ACL).
Perhaps due to this lack of regulation, there has been exponential growth in the BNPL market in Australia and in many other similarly unregulated markets. Consumer advocates argue that this regulatory gap has the potential to create harm in the absence of key consumer protections.
Key Consumer Concerns With BNPL Schemes
“As a minimum, I think putting in place some sort of credit checks to ensure that the product is affordable and suitable for the people. We don’t want to see people who are in the same situation they were in the bad old days of the credit card where they might have had five, six, seven or eight credit cards. No one company knew that the other one had one, and this person was just simply unable to pay off their debts and that’s what we want to address.”
Stephen Jones, Assistant Treasurer and Minister for Financial Services
Some of the issues raised by various stakeholders on BNPL schemes include:
- Unaffordable or inappropriate lending practices contributing to financial stress/hardship;
- Poor complaints handling processes and a lack of hardship assistance;
- Excessive or disproportionate consumer fees and charges (ie large default fees relative to the size of the debt);
- Non-participation in Australia’s credit reporting framework, meaning information is not available for use in credit checks by other lenders;
- Poor product disclosure practices, meaning consumers cannot make informed choices;
- Unsolicited selling targeting consumers and encouraging the use of BNPL for essentials such as groceries and utilities;
- Uncomplicated sign-up to BNPL products, which increases the chances of other consumer harms such as scamming, overselling and financial abuse; and
- Inadequate reverse charging provisions when goods purchased on BNPL are returned.
Three Proposed Options for Regulating BNPL
To resolve some of these issues, the consultation paper proposes three broad options of varying levels of regulatory intervention.
Option 1: Affordability Assessment and a Strengthened Industry Code
Option 1 will impose a bespoke affordability assessment for BNPL providers under the Credit Act and address any other regulatory gaps in a strengthened industry code to make it fit for purpose.
Option 2: Credit Licence and Modified Responsible Lending Obligations
Option 2 will require BNPL providers to obtain and maintain an ACL and, in addition, introduce modified responsible lending obligations under the Credit Act to determine unsuitability, combined with a strengthened industry code.
Option 3: Full Responsible Lending Obligations Under the Credit Act
Option 3 will impose the strictest regulation, with BNPL providers needing to obtain and maintain an ACL.
The existing responsible lending obligations in the Credit Act will also be applied to all BNPL credit, including requirements around reasonable inquiries into a consumer’s financial situation and taking reasonable steps to verify this information.