Following two landmark High Court decisions, the ATO has clarified how businesses should determine whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor. These changes have important implications for payroll tax, superannuation, PAYG withholding and Fair Work obligations.
| Indicator | Employee | Independent contractor |
|---|---|---|
| Control over work | Business directs how, when and where the work is done | Decides how the work is done and largely sets their own hours |
| Delegation | Must perform the work personally | Can subcontract or delegate to others |
| Basis of payment | Paid for time worked, a price per item or a commission | Paid to achieve an agreed result |
| Tools and equipment | Business generally provides tools and equipment | Provides their own tools and equipment |
| Commercial risk | Business carries the risk; work is redone at business cost | Carries their own risk and fixes defects at their own cost |
| Superannuation | Business pays super guarantee | Generally responsible for their own super, though some contractors are covered |
| PAYG withholding | Business withholds tax from wages | Manages their own tax, usually through an ABN |
| Leave entitlements | Entitled to paid leave, or loading if casual | No paid leave entitlements |
High Court decisions that reshaped the rules
The changes stem from two High Court cases decided in 2022:
-
Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd
-
ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd v Jamsek
Together, these cases reshaped how the employee versus contractor distinction is assessed under Australian law.
Personnel Contracting case: Labour hire worker was an employee
In the Personnel Contracting case, the High Court found that a labourer engaged by a labour hire company was an employee, despite being labelled a contractor.
The key factors were:
-
The labour hire company had the right to control how, when and where the labourer worked
-
The company’s core business asset was its ability to supply a compliant workforce
-
The labourer worked under the supervision and direction of others
The Court made it clear that simply calling someone a contractor does not determine their status. This decision overturned an earlier Full Federal Court ruling that had applied a multifactorial test and reached the opposite conclusion.
Jamsek case: Truck drivers were independent contractors
In contrast, the High Court ruled in the Jamsek case that two truck drivers operating through partnerships were not employees.
Key points included:
-
The drivers supplied their own trucks
-
They operated through business structures
-
The arrangement was consistent with long-standing treatment of transport operators as contractors
The Court confirmed that, in this context, the relationship was characteristic of independent contracting rather than employment.
ATO response: Taxation Ruling TR 2023/4
In response to these decisions, the ATO released Taxation Ruling TR 2023/4.
The ruling confirms that whether a worker is an employee under the ordinary meaning of the term is a question of fact, determined by an objective assessment of the legal rights and obligations between the parties.
Why the written contract now matters most
Under the ruling, where the parties have:
-
Fully documented their relationship in a written contract
-
Not challenged the contract as a sham
-
Not varied, waived or replaced the contract
Then the written contract alone is the primary source used to determine the worker’s status.
Importantly, how the parties actually behave in practice cannot be used to recharacterise the relationship, unless that conduct is relevant to establishing the terms of the contract or challenging its validity under contract law.
Traditional employment indicators still apply, but differently
Indicators such as:
-
Control or right to control
-
Ability to delegate or subcontract work
-
Responsibility for risk
-
Ability to generate goodwill
-
Working to achieve a result
Still matter, but only to the extent that they are reflected in the legal rights and obligations set out in the contract.
They are no longer assessed by looking at day-to-day work practices alone.
Holistic assessment of the contract
The ruling emphasises that determining worker status requires a holistic review of the contract as a whole.
This involves stepping back and forming an informed, qualitative view of the overall legal relationship, rather than focusing on individual clauses in isolation.
Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2023/2
Alongside the ruling, the ATO released Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2023/2.
This guideline outlines how the ATO will approach compliance and enforcement where businesses engage workers and classify them as employees or independent contractors. It provides guidance on risk areas and the likelihood of ATO review.
What this means for businesses
Businesses should:
-
Review all contractor agreements carefully
-
Ensure contracts accurately reflect the intended relationship
-
Avoid relying on labels alone
-
Seek advice where arrangements may sit near the boundary
Misclassification can lead to significant liabilities, including unpaid superannuation, PAYG withholding, penalties and interest.
Speak to our accountants
Speak to one of our accountants if you have any questions about the changes in tax for 2023.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an employee and a contractor?
An employee generally works in your business and is subject to your direction and control, while a contractor runs their own business and provides services to you. The distinction matters because it affects tax withholding, superannuation, leave entitlements, workers compensation and other obligations.
How do I work out if a worker is an employee or a contractor?
You need to look at the whole working relationship, not just the label in the contract. Relevant factors include who controls how the work is done, whether the worker can delegate or subcontract, who supplies tools and equipment, how the worker is paid, and whether they operate their own business.
Have the rules for classifying workers changed?
Yes. Recent changes to workplace laws mean the real substance and practical reality of the working relationship must be considered, rather than relying mainly on the written contract. Businesses that engage contractors should review existing arrangements to confirm workers are classified correctly.
Do I need to pay super for contractors?
Sometimes. If a contractor is paid mainly for their labour under a contract, they may be treated as an employee for super guarantee purposes, even if they have an ABN. Check each arrangement carefully, as unpaid super can lead to the super guarantee charge and penalties.
What happens if I classify a worker incorrectly?
Misclassifying an employee as a contractor can result in back payments of wages, entitlements and super, as well as PAYG withholding penalties and interest. Deliberately disguising employment as a contracting arrangement is known as sham contracting and can attract significant penalties.